Affiliate Marketing and Print-On-Demand are 2 popular models that allow you to work from the comfort of your home.
With little to zero upfront cost and no inventory, both seem like appealing and lucrative options. But are there any challenges you should know about?
Dive into our affiliate marketing vs. print-on-demand comparison to see which model best suits your needs and objectives.
Let’s get started!
Start creating for Free!
Showcase your E-commerce products like big brands, without costing a fortune
Affiliate Marketing vs. Print-On-Demand: Quick Comparison
Before we dive deeper, here’s a quick comparison of affiliate marketing and POD.
Affiliate Marketing: Overview
Affiliate marketing involves promoting products from other companies and earning a commission for each sale through your referral or affiliate links.
An affiliate link is a unique URL that contains your ID or username, allowing online marketers to promote products or services.
You get it when you join a brand’s affiliate marketing program.
When online visitors click on this link, they are directed to the company’s website.
If they buy a product, the purchase is tracked to you, enabling you to earn a commission for driving traffic and generating sales for the business.
You can offer visitors promo codes with discounts, special offers, etc. Moreover, you can also provide a list of affiliate links in your link in bio.
Thus, if a visitor clicks on any of the links and makes a purchase, you’ll get a predetermined commission.
The primary focus is on driving traffic and conversions rather than handling product fulfillment.
Types of Affiliate Marketing
There are 3 types of affiliate marketing:
- Unattached — You have no personal connection or expertise related to the product or service you’re promoting.
For example, you run pay-per-click ads for home deco items without personally using or endorsing these products.
- Related — Involves promoting products relevant to your existing audience, industry, niche, etc., even if you haven’t used the products yourself.
Let’s say you are a beauty blogger writing about makeup trends, and you decide to promote a popular lipstick brand.
Although you haven’t personally used that lipstick, you believe it will resonate with your audience who are interested in beauty products.
This type of marketing typically sees higher engagement than unattached marketing due to your established relationship with their audience.
- Involved — Implies that you have a personal connection with a product or service since you used or are using it.
For instance, you are a fitness enthusiast or a blogger who uses specific sports brands or equipment, and you share your positive experience with them.
Leveraging your personal experience helps you build trust and credibility within your community.
Potential buyers are more likely to trust recommendations from someone with firsthand experience.
1. Initial Costs
This model generally has lower startup costs since you don’t need to create products.
However, while the barriers to entry are lower, there are still certain expenses you should consider.
For example, investing in website hosting is essential for establishing an online presence where you can share your affiliate content.
Domain registration is another necessary expense, as a domain name is crucial for branding and making your website easily accessible to your audience.
In addition, you may want to use various marketing tools to enhance your strategies, such as email marketing platforms, social media scheduling tools, SEO software, etc.
On the positive side, you can initially opt for solutions that have Freemium plans or Free trials to see how well they work for you.
📌 Extra Tip:
One of the strategies for affiliate marketing is creating YouTube videos. Unlike website hosting, it’s free, and you may reach a wider audience more easily.
The most popular affiliate marketing strategies on YouTube include:
- Unboxing videos — Videos where you unbox certain products or items and provide links in the video description that visitors can use to buy a product or get a special discount.
- Product Reviews — Videos where you review products you’ve tried based on your audience’s demands.
You should provide an honest review, and include both the pros and cons of the product.
- Tutorials and How-To Videos — Videos where you show how to use a certain product, highlight the key features, share life hacks related to specific products, etc.
In addition to YouTube videos, you can also create YouTube shorts. They follow the same practices as YouTube videos but in a shorter and more engaging format.
2. Profit Margins
In affiliate marketing, profit margins are often lower since you earn commissions rather than selling products directly.
Commission rates typically range from 5% to 30%, depending on the affiliate program and the products you promote.
Unlike POD, where you, as a seller, can control pricing, you are subject to the commission structures set by the sellers you partner with in affiliate marketing.
Consequently, this can lead to less predictable income.
📌 Note:
On the positive side, affiliate marketing can yield fast income. Remember the YouTube videos we mentioned?
If you publish affiliate marketing-focused videos, you can earn money sooner than by publishing the same content on your website.
One of the reasons is that YouTube doesn’t separate small from big channels, making it easier to be spotted.
3. Time and Effort
While you need significant effort in marketing strategies and engaging with the audience, the operational overhead is typically lower than in traditional business models.
The main reason is that you don’t have to handle product management or inventory, nor are you responsible for customer service issues after the purchase.
Instead, your role revolves around creating compelling content, leveraging social media and affiliate marketing platforms, and various marketing techniques to drive traffic to the merchant’s website.
Additionally, affiliate marketing offers diverse opportunities across multiple niches, allowing you to select products or services that align with your interests or expertise.
4. Skills Set
The first major difference between these 2 models might be the skill set you need for affiliate marketing.
Affiliate marketing isn’t necessarily too difficult but requires more skills than the POD business model.
For starters, you need to learn what kind of content to create and do it in such a way to add value to the product, enticing a potential buyer to click on your link.
5. Risks
While affiliate marketing can be lucrative, it doesn’t come without any risks.
One significant risk involves promoting untrustworthy products or companies.
5.1. Promotions
If you recommend a product that turns out to be of poor quality or if the company fails to deliver on its promises, this can severely damage your credibility and reputation.
Trust is paramount in establishing and maintaining a loyal audience, and any misstep may result in a loss of followers, customers, and, ultimately, income.
5.2. Commission Structures
Another potential impediment is changing commission structures.
Companies may alter their payment models, reduce commission rates, or implement stricter terms and conditions without prior notice.
5.3. Legal Terms
Additionally, you may also face challenges related to compliance and regulations.
As the industry grows, guidelines regarding advertising disclosures and privacy laws are becoming stricter.
Therefore, failing to adhere to these regulations can result in penalties or legal repercussions.
Affiliate Marketing: Pros & Cons
🟢 Low initial investment with minimal risk.
🟢 No need for inventory or customer service.
🟢 Quick entry into the market with various affiliate programs available.
🔴 Lower profit margins compared to selling your products.
🔴 High competition in popular niches.
🔴 Low pricing control.
Print-on-Demand (POD): Overview
Print-on-demand model allows you to create and sell custom-designed products without holding inventory.
Products are printed and shipped only when customers order, minimizing upfront costs and inventory risks.
1. Initial Costs
One of the biggest appeals of POD is low entry costs. Initially, starting your POD can be totally free if you use design tools with Freemium or Free Trial options.
Naturally, as your business picks up, you’ll probably want to invest in more advanced tools or subscriptions, but you can do it without additional costs for starters.
However, you must consider the fees of the marketplaces and eCommerce sites where you will host your online store.
2. Profit Margins
In the print-on-demand business model, profit margins typically range from 25% to 50%.
Various factors affect this range, including pricing strategies, production costs, and the specific products you sell.
In addition, the margins can vary depending on the supplier, the quality of materials, and the complexity of the designs.
POD has a medium earnings potential and a medium speed of earning. However, let that not discourage you.
Yes, the growth may be slower, but POD is consistent and, more importantly, a reliable business model.
Thus, it can be a good choice if you want a side hustle and an extra income.
On top of that, you have the flexibility to set prices based on market demand and to adjust pricing strategies to optimize profits.
3. Time and Effort
When starting a POD business, you may need to invest more time in product research, design creation, finding the right POD supplier, choosing a marketplace or eCommerce platform, etc.
However, once you’ve done that, you don’t need to exert much effort. The process will then go almost automatically.
💡 ProTip:
Did you know you can automate your POD operations, from product designs over fulfillment to marketing?
We’ve covered the topic in great length in our blog, How to Fully Automate Your Print-on-Demand Business? so you can find out more.
By automating your operations, you can streamline workflow and minimize manual labor.
Dynamic Mockups, an automated mockup generator, provides integrations with eCommerce platforms like Etsy and WooCommerce to automate your listing updates.
In addition, you can automate mockup creations with Adobe, WordPress, Zapier, and Make integrations.
4. Skills Set
POD is a model that requires little to no skills. At its core, it’s all about creating and uploading designs to POD platforms where customers can buy them.
In the past, you had to rely on professional graphic designers or expensive photoshoots to portray your products or services, but luckily, you no longer have to.
Thanks to mockup generators, you can easily and quickly:
- Pick and edit product templates,
- Customize them and align them with your brand and target audience.
💡 ProTip:
With Dynamic Mockups, you can upload multiple designs and color combinations and automatically get all mockup variations.
100 mockups in 10 seconds, to be more precise.
Moreover, you can browse and pick mockups from our Mockup Library, including:
T-shirts, hoodies, wall art, pillows, tote bags, mugs, and more.
5. Risks
While the print-on-demand business model offers numerous opportunities, it has challenges.
One of the most common issues is product quality control.
Since you depend on 3rd-party suppliers to produce and fulfill orders, you skip direct oversight of the manufacturing process.
Consequently, there is an inherent risk that the quality of the products may not meet your customer expectations.
If customers receive items of low quality, with incorrect designs, or they don’t match the descriptions, it can lead to complaints and returns.
Such issues not only frustrate customers but also have the potential to tarnish your brand reputation, resulting in negative reviews and diminished customer loyalty.
💡 ProTip:
Introducing our embeddable iFrame Mockup Editor, which allows you to generate mockups directly on your website or platform.
With this editor, your customers can design high-quality mockups without leaving your site.
Besides streamlining the design process, the greatest benefit is that you have complete control over print quality, ensuring that each project aligns with your standards.
By minimizing data transfers and reducing printing errors, you can achieve a more efficient workflow that saves time.
Print-On-Demand: Pros & Cons
🟢 No inventory management or upfront product costs.
🟢 Ability to build a personal brand with custom products.
🟢 Higher profit margins and price control.
🔴 Potential issues with product quality and shipping.
🔴 Has a medium speed of earning.
🔴 Initially, it is more time-consuming than affiliate marketing.
Affiliate Marketing vs. Print-On-Demand: Which One is The Best for You?
There isn’t a straightforward answer to this question.
If you are a novice, POD is probably a better option since it doesn’t require a special set of skills or previous experience.
On the other hand, affiliate marketing may be a better choice if you already have some experience in POD or online marketing and have your audience.
Overall, your choice doesn’t have to be exclusive, either-or.
You can create your niche-specific POD store and connect with influencers, bloggers, etc., to do affiliate marketing.
How To Kickstart Your POD with Dynamic Mockups?
Regardless of your product, the POD business starts with high-quality, scroll-stopping mockups.
Dynamic Mockups enables you to generate mockups in bulk in a matter of seconds and eliminates common risks regarding POD, such as print quality and misplaced designs.
Thus, you can:
🔥 Effortlessly position, resize, and fit your assets with automatic adjustments.
🔥 Personalize and customize mockups to not only meet your needs but also look realistic via:
- AI Generator that allows you to create and switch backgrounds without affecting your original designs.
Just provide a text prompt, and our AI tool will generate a new background or scene.
- Unlimited color options, including built-in Printful and Printify palettes.
- Photoshop-style effects to add a more realistic touch.
- Uploading your own or existing Photoshop mockups for further customization.
And so much more.
Start with Dynamic Mockups for free to launch your POD effortlessly.
Start creating for Free!
Showcase your E-commerce products like big brands, without costing a fortune
Keep Learning:
6 Key Benefits of Print-on-Demand Business
